Magazines. T-Shirts. Design & Creative Books. Stationery. Building a Consumer Brand. The Entrepreneurial Ride of a Lifetime.

Archive for the ‘The Inside Story’ Category

High Powered Conversations at Mag Nation HQ

Friday, August 6th, 2010

It’s not all fun and games at Mag Nation HQ. From time to time, we get involved in some really heavy issues. The email exchange below is completely unedited from start to finish, with the exception of a client name to protect their identity. Seriously.

From: Mag Nation Queen St.
Sent: Wed 04-Aug-10 11:50 a.m.
To: Ravi Pathare
Subject: Gay mags

Ravi,

(Insert unnamed IVF clinic here) have an account with us to send them porn once a month but we don’t get any Gay porn titles anymore, can we put them back on order?

mag nation
100 Queen Street
PO Box 106196
Auckland CBD
Tel: 3666 216

________________________________

From: Ravi Pathare
Sent: Wed 4/08/2010 12:02
To: Mag Nation Queen St.
Subject: RE: Gay mags

How many gay porn titles do they want per month and what nos. of each?

Ravi Pathare
Managing Director
Mag Nation Pty Ltd
100 Queen St.

________________________________

From: Mag Nation Queen St.
Sent: Wed 04-Aug-10 12:05 p.m.
To: Ravi Pathare
Subject: RE: Gay mags

Two a month, along with two straight porn and one mens mag. I have the others on hold waiting to send out once a couple of gay titles come in, but DNA/Attidude are just lifestyle magazines

mag nation
100 Queen Street
PO Box 106196
Auckland CBD
Tel: 3666 216

________________________________

From: Ravi Pathare
Sent: Wed 4/08/2010 13:16
To: Mag Nation Queen St.
Subject: RE: Gay mags

Understand. For the intended purpose, DNA/Attitude simply won’t cut it.

Ravi Pathare
Managing Director
Mag Nation Pty Ltd
100 Queen St.
Auckland
New Zealand.

________________________________

From: Vali Valibhoy
Sent: Wed 04-Aug-10 1:20 p.m.
To: Ravi Pathare
Subject: Re: Gay mags

________________________________

From: Ravi Pathare
Sent: Wed 4/08/2010 13:22
To: Mag Nation Queen St.
Subject: RE: Gay mags

Mama Mia?

Ravi

________________________________

From: Vali Valibhoy
Sent: Wed 04-Aug-10 1:50 p.m.
To: Ravi Pathare
Subject: Re: Gay mags

This is destined for the blog.

________________________________

Hot drinks and magazines

Monday, August 2nd, 2010

In the wake of a very small mention at the end of an article on Chai tea in The Age recently, Chai sales at our Melbourne stores have gone through the roof. We’re talking like, a 400% increase. Which is pretty much bananas, when you consider that of ‘Ten Places to Try’, we’re listed right near the end at number seven!

It has to be said, though, that we don’t really sell a lot of hot drinks. Which is a constant source of befuddlement for us… ’cause in addition to our Chai all other flavours of tea, we make a pretty darn good coffee!

It’s not extracted from beans shat out by Indonesian monkeys nor is it Clover extracted single origin, you know, coffee nerd coffee but if we do say so ourselves, we make a pretty tasty cup of joe.

It’s with some bewilderment then, that we’ll occasionally see customers queued up out the doors of the coffee chain next to our Melbourne CBD store while our machine trickles out just the occasional latte. So, as a special offer you, blog readers, if you come into our Elizabeth Street store this week (Monday, 2nd of August — Friday, 6th August) and bring in a friend (with a printed copy of this blog post) and introduce them to our delicious espresso, then we’ll happily give each of you a coffee on us. On the house. Gratis. Free.

(Yeah, yeah, we know, we are the nicest guys in magazine/coffee retail. What can we say?)

Mag Nation’s Founder says goodbye

Wednesday, July 14th, 2010

This is the last blog entry I will write as the MD of mag nation. Monday morning, I sent out the following email to my entire contact database:

Dear Friends, Colleagues and Professional Acquaintances,

It is with both a tinge of nervousness but moreover great excitement and anticipation for the future that I inform you that this coming Friday is my last day at the helm of mag nation.

I co-founded the company 5 years ago, and have overseen the creation of a wonderful challenger brand that has built a deep cult-like adoration amongst its fans. The time has now come for me to seek out my next challenge.

I leave the day to day management of my company in the hands of my wonderful team who have developed out of sight. mag nation is performing better than ever before in its history, and I remain convinced that our industry disruptive model and innovative approach towards a staid and tired model has the most exciting future.

I will obviously maintain close involvement with the company in an advisory capacity. Even though I have decided to seek out a larger playing field, mag nation will always be my baby and my brand, and I remain emotionally connected to it. I will always be mag nation’s Founder.

While I will retain and be checking my mag nation email address, I have set up a new one: XXX My phone contact XXX will remain the same.

My co-founder Ravi Pathare will continue as the overall Managing Director of the Company. Vali Valibhoy who is our Operations Manager here in Australia will be the key point of contact for our Australian day to day operations, while Oliver Palmer will be the point of call for all things marketing and website related.

I would like to thank all of the people who have touched my life in some way during the creation of mag nation. I encourage you to continue your support of mag nation, and look forward to maintaining contact with you as I continue my professional journey.

Best wishes
Sahil

Other than my 3 children, mag nation has been the most amazing thing I have ever been involved with. As those of you who read my first ever blog entry will know, I have put my heart, soul and every ounce of my being into mag nation. I will miss it immensely and feel that I am leaving behind a part of me. The character, tone and values of the brand have been an extension of myself.

Ultimately however, what has made mag nation has been all the customers and supporters who choose to interact with us as opposed to the other options presented to them. To every single person who has ever walked through our doors, bought from us online, tweeted us or simply mentioned us to a friend (including the infamous Angry City of Melbourne Taxpayer), I am indebted to you.

Thanks to all of you for what has been the most amazing journey. One that for me personally is only beginning (I am still just 36 years old), but that is about to enter a new chapter.

Sahil

Don’t know whether to laugh, cry or be very concerned

Thursday, July 1st, 2010

This is a piece of feedback we received via our website. I have not edited it one iota other than taking out the name of the author.

I just wanted to complement Mag Nation on their phenomenal choice in staffing at the Prahran store. I live just around the corner from the store. Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Monday every week its babes babes babes. Those three fine women are a real calling card for the Prahran Mag Nation and are a big reason I keep spending.A bit too shy to ask to her face. Would Miss Monday be free one night? I think some sparks could really fly,I m a handsome dude and you a total babe. What you say? My emails attached.

That is verbatim folks. Babes, babes, babes eh? Now, I thought we had a guy with a bushy beard working there one day a week.

In any case, I am glad that the author of this missive finds some reason to spend money in our store. Perhaps it may have been preferable if it was because of our amazing magazine selection but hey, beggars can’t be choosers.

As for referring to one of our lovely staff members as Miss Monday – well, that has got me thinking… Mag nation staff calendar, perhaps? I vote for being Mr March. I’ll even shave my chest.

NB: To my staff members who are reading this blog. I am being flippant. Please do not polish up your resignation letters just yet, and I sincerely apologise for making you think of your boss and his hairy chest.

Scathing Criticism of Mag Nation

Wednesday, May 19th, 2010

Someone has just written the same comment on 7 of our most recent blog posts. Rather than approving the comment 7 times and hijacking the conversation on those posts away from their intended topic, we have decided to dedicate a separate post to this particular comment. It is replicated (in full) below:





What I would like to know “Mag-Nation” is how a NZ company (which all the profits go back overseas) can claim $30k in government grants for a website from Melbourne city council, (funded by the tax payer) to run a glorified newsagency under the label that its an innovative business?

With content in your “about us” section like – “All the girls who work at mag nation are gorgeous. All the boys have big schlongs.” I’m shocked that the Melbourne City Council thinks its a good idea to fund such blatantly sexist, boorish content.

Not only that, this “Undies Monday” is STOLEN from Gaslight Music who used to have a once a year nude event to raise money for public radio!

So in short – $30,000 of taxpayer funds for a disgusting sexist website, and stolen ideas from other companies.

“Mag-Nation” does not constitute an “innovative” business. More like an innovative way of ripping off other peoples idea’s and wrapping them up in SMUT to make corporate profits that get sent overseas.

WASTE OF TAXPAYER DOLLARS!!!!

Signed:
Angry City Of Melbourne Taxpayer.
(who doubts this message will even be posted in its entirety)





A few thoughts in response Mr/Mrs Taxpayer.

1. It was 15K, not 30K

2. We “started” in NZ, but we are an Australian registered company. The NZ company is a subsidiary of our Australian Parent company. All profits (or losses) stay in the Aus entity.

3. We never claimed Undies Monday was original. We in fact openly admit the inspiration came from Gaslight. See this link and the comments.

4. The Australian Retail Association also awarded us “most innovative retailer” in 2007

5. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. We respect yours, and your right to not shop or engage with us. The City of Melbourne obviously had their own opinion as well.

6. We did post this in its entirety.

Mag Nation is trying to take down “da man” – want to help us?

Tuesday, May 11th, 2010

Apparently we are not the only ones selling magazine subscriptions online in Australia and New Zealand. Thanks Gran. Without your online vigilance, I definitely would never have heard of Poo-Subscribe and BumShop.

Ok, now I know it is really immature of me to refer to my competitors using the words poo and bum. There is nothing inherently wrong with them after all. They are not bad people. They are just… well… not me. And every dollar spent with them is a potential dollar not spent with mag nation. And they are rich and I am poor. So I don’t like them. And immature as it may be, it is still fun to dis them.

As good and sophisticated as we think we might be online, we are never going to be a match for their huge budgets and teams of staff. When you Google most Aus/NZ magazines, they come up first in organic search, and the masses who should be buying from us (because we are way cooler) end up clicking on the top link and buying from them.

How are we to compete? Our stores kick arse over their stores… wait… in fact they don’t have stores (says me smiling and poking out my tongue). But the one big thing that we have that they don’t is you!

Can you help us? Please? Pretty please? We will also try to reward you and make it worth your while. We believe in mutual loving after all.

If any of you have a favourite magazine (and if you don’t, I question what you are doing reading this blog in the first place), perhaps you could review it on your website / blog / online space. It would have to be a genuine website / blog / online space because the key component would be to fill it with content rich key words (thanks for that technical term Ollee) and link it through to the landing page of that particular mag on our website. Or if that is too much work, perhaps just a link on your blog roll with anchor text something like “mag nation has the best magazine subscriptions – much better than all those other pretenders”. Ok, maybe just mentioning mag nation and magazine subscriptions might be enough.

Apparently Google likes in-bound links. Maybe, just maybe, we might be able to erode some of their organic search market dominance. In return for all your efforts, we would name you a mag nation VIP. Other than sounding really really impressive and winning you amazing kudos at parties, it would also get you lots of other really cool benefits. We just haven’t worked out what they are yet.

What do you say friends? Are you willing to aid and abet our attempts to take down da man? Please give us a shout if the answer is yes and we can talk turkey!

AGIdeas – the mag nation wash up

Wednesday, May 5th, 2010

Last Thursday saw the end of one of our busiest periods in the year. The AGIdeas conference in Melbourne is a massive event, and an opportunity for us to create a pop up retail stall selling books and mags.

As always, it was incredibly well run, with an amazing line up of speakers. All participants we spoke to came away inspired and fired up for another year of creative pursuits.

However, this year our sales from the pop up stall were about half of what they were last year. We don’t really make any profit from our presence at the conference anyway – it really is an opportunity to get our brand name out there, however, the sales performance was a curiosity. When I mentioned this to a couple of people at the stall, they were interested in the reasons underpinning the lower sales, and at the time, I didn’t have a really coherent answer. A couple of factors now come to mind. It took us a few days to analyse all the sales, but we think we now have the reasons pegged:

  • We didn’t have the same number of star new releases. Last year Wooden Toy, King Brown and Curvy, had all just released their latest issues. This year, we had in the new King Brown and T-World, but some of our other best sellers are still to arrive.
  • Not as many of the speakers this year had books or magazines that sold in high volumes.
  • This year was the 20th Year Anniversary of AGIdeas. As such, each participant was given a massive book which celebrated the 20 years of speakers. This thing weighed well over 3 kilos and required 2 hands to carry. Definitely not conducive to people buying books at the same time.
  • A number of free back copies of various mags were given away to participants. This was done after discussion with us, so we were in the know, but people are less inclined to buy stuff after receiving a bunch of freebies as well.
  • The volcano in Iceland delayed a shipment of some of our more interesting books, meaning they didn’t come out until later on the second day.
  • The retail economy sucks. While the niche mags we specialise in may not have suffered, we hear from book retailers that book sales are well down. Also, most people have under-estimated just how much of an impact the government stimulus package had last year on maintaining retail sales.

All in all, we were again happy with our involvement with this fantastic event. Our main aim was to remind people that we exist. With no real budget for advertising, we see these sorts of events as an important extension of our store presence.

However, when you budget for sales of $X, and you end up doing around half of that, it doesn’t do a great amount for your cash flow forecasts. Looks like my kids are going to be serving behind the counter at a few stores in the coming weeks to make up the shortfall!

Happy birthday to us…

Friday, March 26th, 2010

This week mag nation turned four years old. To the 399 potential investors who laughed at us and said we wouldn’t last more than a year – suffer in your jocks. Ok, so you guys are all probably rich beyond belief anyway, but nothing helped spur us on more than beyond wealthy know-it-alls telling us that no one would ever care about a specialty magazine retail concept.

As for the approximate 4 million customers who have walked through our doors, thanks for caring about a specialty magazine retail concept! Thanks for interacting with us, watching us grow, laughing with us (and occasionally at us), stripping down to your undies for us (with a fair dose of self-interest thrown in), drinking our coffee and most importantly, loving our mags.

It has undoubtedly been a wild ride so far, and we are looking forward to the next four years with great anticipation. What will the face of print look like? Will the iPad impact magazine sales? Which mainstream mags will fold and who will be the new Frankie? Hopefully a presence in Brisvegas and other Australian cities? Maybe even new international horizons…

It is with a real sense of optimism that we quietly pass the four year mark without much fanfare (other than this blog post!). While we have made some real strategic errors along the way, our biggest learning has been that as long as we keep an open dialogue with you, we can’t go too far wrong. Whether it be tactical advice on how to grow our website or more philosophical questions around brand integrity versus the commercial imperative to sell, who needs a Board of Advisors when we have you?

So thanks once again for engaging with us. Retailers are constantly reminded that customers vote with their feet, and we keep on seeing our traffic in store and online increasing, so it is good to know we are doing something right. We hope to continue to serve you with great magazines, designer stationery, creative books, and online subscriptions. More than anything, however, we look forward to continue having fun with you, creating smiles through some (at times loose) connection to magazines, and filling a void in your lives irrespective of whether it relates to magazine availability, receiving a newsletter that makes you chuckle, or simply where you can kill some time when you need to.

Happy birthday to us… but the fact we have made it to four is more about you.

Asking for your help with e-commerce and online subscriptions

Thursday, March 4th, 2010

We sell magazines. We have never proclaimed to be e-commerce experts, and we don’t have millions of dollars to throw at acquiring these skills like some of our competitors do. That is why it is with some excitement but also trepidation that we have seen the growth of our online subscription business far outstrip any of our physical stores.

Some of you folk, who are much cleverer than we are, live and breathe in this space. Can we ask for your help and advice?

We are looking at updating and improving our site, and in going through all the stats from Google Analytics, we have noticed that our drop off from people entering our cart through to final purchase is pretty high.

What is normal? Does anyone have some benchmarks that they could throw our way?

We thought we would lose heaps of people through the “fill in your details” steps. Subscriptions are a little more complicated than a normal book purchase because you often send it to someone else rather than yourself. However, our drop off at these points in the transaction process is minimal. Rather, most people who do abandon our purchase process do so at the final point of purchase.

That is, they take the time to add a magazine subscription to their cart, signup for an account, provide us with all their details, get to the final payment page, and then piss off elsewhere.

We were really surprised by this. Not so much by the quantum of abandonment, but the point of abandonment. We realise that many people are going to “chicken out” prior to pressing pay, but are there things we could be doing to improve our conversion?

Some of the things we are about to implement include:

  • Integrating PayPal
  • Highlighting that our payment system is “secure”
  • Increasing the size of the Pay Now button

We already changed the colour of our checkout button in the shopping cart from red (part of our brand identity) to green, and saw via A/B testing that conversion from that point increased.

Should we change from “pay now” to “buy now”? Any other clever ideas? Help!!!

If we end up implementing any individual’s suggestion, we’ll happily provide you with a lifetime supply of magazines ala Mr Wonka. Ok, maybe not, but how about a $100 mag nation voucher instead???

The Yoda of Magazines

Monday, February 15th, 2010

Meet Ravi. He is one of the two founders of mag nation. Much less in the public eye than I am (Sahil), he is every bit a driving force of mag nation as is the guy writing this blog. He also happens to be one of the smartest blokes around.

Ravi is a medical doctor. Moreover, he is a Pathologist. So, when he’s not busy building a retail empire, he diagnoses rare diseases in his spare time, which is a useful skill to have in this industry. Okay, not really.

When he migrated to New Zealand from India, the New Zealand government wouldn’t recognise his qualifications. (Which is pretty crazy stuff when you consider that could have taught many of the local doctors a thing or two about Pathology, having dealt with all sorts of weird diseases during his time on the sub-continent. But, I digress…)

Because he wanted a different life for his family, Ravi left India and gave up years of study and a thriving private practise in the process. Unable to practise medicine in New Zealand and with no non-medical business experience behind him, he bought a small convenience store called Mega Mags in Queen St in Auckland. From there, the mag nation concept was born.

This bloke is a rocket scientist. Genius mind. He is also my uncle. And he is incredibly precious to me. My second child’s middle name is in honour of the guy.

When we began to plan what would later become mag nation, he did everything he could to talk me out of it. He told me that I had a real future in the corporate world, family responsibilities, and that I shouldn’t risk everything on a dream. Only when I proved my stubbornness did he relent and welcome me to his world of being broke.

At 55 years old, Ravi is no spring chicken. In fact, a publisher we often deal with referred to him recently as ‘the Yoda of Magazines’. He is known globally (he has spoken twice at Colophon) and there are few people with more knowledge of magazine retail supply than he has. Yet, he is also remarkably young in his outlook.

For a brand that takes such a different and at times irreverent approach, people are often surprised to find out that neither of the founders are in their 20s.

Virtually all the mags that you see in mag nation are there because Ravi decided that they should be and could be. He is the sort of bloke who can memorise spreadsheets worth of data and regurgitate pricing and margins at a moments notice. He is also the guy who when discussing creating subscription terminals in-store and how to avoid theft of equipment, suggested that we glue the mouse to the table. It took him 30 seconds to realize why the rest of us where wetting our pants. We all have our slips.

More than all else, he is a good bloke. If you are going to bet your entire future on a business, might as well be with someone you trust. There is no blame, recrimination or singular credit amongst the two of us. Though all of this is totally irrelevant to the average customer walking into our stores, I genuinely hope you feel something intangible but special when walking into a mag nation store.

If you do, then you are feeling the presence of the Yoda of Magazines.

(‘Ravi Yoda’ illustration by the inimitable Tyson Savanah from our Elizabeth Street store.)